Each of the drive tests may test different parameters.
So a drive can fail on one and pass on another.
Also some of the tests are to predict failure which may be inaccurate.
For example HD Tune, HD Sentinel, Crystal Disk, etc. may have different scoring systems for alerts, cautions, warnings, scores, etc.
If you were to contact HP or Dell or Lenovo, etc. they would want to know the results of the Sea Tools long generic test or long DST.
These are the tests typically used for warranty replacement.